Monitored vs auto‑dial personal alarms: What you should know

When an emergency happens, every second is critical. One thing you shouldn't have to worry about in that moment is who can help and how quickly they can come.

Many people don’t realise there’s a huge difference between monitored personal alarms and auto‑dial alarms (also called non‑monitored, self‑monitored, or family‑monitored alarms). The names sound reassuring… but the truth is that auto‑dial alarms are not monitored at all. They simply send out a call or text — and hope someone sees it, answers it, and knows what to do.

‍

Recently, auto‑dial alarms made the news for all the wrong reasons. In the 2023 Choice Shonky Awards, they were called out for being unreliable and difficult to use — or as Choice bluntly put it: “An emergency device that you can’t rely on in an emergency? Sounds pretty shonky to us.”

Want clarity, confidence, and peace of mind when it matters most? Keep reading — your future self will thank you.

‍

Personal alarms: What they are and why they matter

A personal alarm is a small device — often worn as a pendant or watch — that allows you to call for help in an emergency. Many models include helpful safety features such as fall detection, GPS, two‑way voice communication and water resistance.
For people living alone, at risk of falls, managing health conditions, or simply wanting extra peace of mind, a personal alarm ensures help can be reached quickly when it matters most.

‍

What Is a monitored personal alarm?

A personal alarm that connects to a 24/7 emergency response centre is known as a monitored alarm. When the alarm is activated, every call is answered promptly by trained professionals who assess the situation, organise the right help, and stay with you to provide support and reassurance until assistance arrives.

At MePACS, our responders are trained in first aid and Triple Zero protocols, so they know exactly which questions to ask and what actions to take in an emergency.

Monitored alarms provide a truly client‑focused service. When you activate an alert, we immediately know who you are, and your important medical details — including medications, allergies and health conditions — are already securely stored on file. If emergency services are required, we share the relevant information with them so they can prioritise and tailor their response appropriately.
Also, even if you are unable to communicate during the emergency, we already have your details and send help to wherever you are.

This creates a dependable safety net that is both personalised and effective when you need it most.

‍

What is an Auto-Dial personal alarm?

An auto‑dial personal alarm may look similar to a monitored alarm, but it operates very differently. Instead of connecting to a professional response centre, it simply calls or sends a message to a list of pre‑programmed contacts — usually family or friends — when activated. The device tries the first number on the list, and if there’s no answer, it moves to the next.

A key limitation is that family and friends are not always available to respond. Work, travel, sleep, or other commitments can prevent them from answering at the moment help is needed, which can lead to delays. In addition, personal contacts may not have the knowledge or confidence to assess the situation or take appropriate action.

Some auto‑dial alarms can also call Triple Zero, but you must be able to speak clearly and provide the necessary details for help to be dispatched.

Given these factors, an auto‑dial alarm is not a considered a reliable safety option by many care professionals.

‍

‍

Features and benefits comparison

To help you choose the safest option, the table below highlights the key differences between monitored and auto‑dial alarms. In simple terms, monitored alarms offer consistent, professional 24/7 response, while auto‑dial alarms depend on personal contacts being available and able to act.

For anyone with health risks, a history of falls or periods of time spent alone, these differences can significantly impact how quickly help reaches you.

‍

	Monitored	Non-Monitored (Auto-dial)
Guaranteed response 24/7, 365 days a year	✔︎	✘
Quick response	✔︎ (Within 2 minutes)	✘  (Can be delayed until a contact answers)
Professional responders trained to handle emergencies	✔︎	✘
Relevant Medical information shared with emergency services	✔︎	✘
Stay in contact until help arrives	✔︎	✘
Upfront device cost	✔︎  (No device cost for the Home Alarm)	✔︎
Monthly monitoring charge	✔︎  (No contract, cancel any time)	✘
SIM card included in cost	✔︎	✘ (Only included in the first year)
Call and SMS charges included in cost	✔︎	✘  (Only included in the first year)

‍

‍

Why price isn’t the whole story: Understanding the real value of monitoring

It’s completely natural to compare prices when choosing a personal alarm. At first glance, auto‑dial alarms seem cheaper because they don’t have ongoing monitoring fees. But it’s important to look at what that lower price actually means — and what you may be compromising when you need help the most.

Monitoring fees aren’t just a subscription — they’re a guarantee that trained professionals will answer every single alert, day or night, and get you the right help. No delays. No voicemail. No struggling to reach your phone when you’re injured.

Put simply: it’s not the alarm that saves a life — it’s the dedicated response service behind it.

Many people buy an alarm because they want the certainty that, in an emergency, someone will respond quickly and know what to do. A monitored alarm delivers that certainty. An auto‑dial alarm depends entirely on luck and availability.

So yes, auto‑dial alarms may not have ongoing fees — but monitored alarms give you something far more valuable: reliable help when you really need it.

‍

---

‍

How to Choose the Right Personal Alarm

Choosing the right personal alarm comes down to your individual needs — your lifestyle, your level of independence, your health, and the kind of support you want around you.

While auto‑dial alarms can seem appealing because they have no ongoing fees, it’s important to understand what you may be giving up in terms of safety and peace of mind. Even Choice has been unable to recommend any auto‑dial alarms since 2017, stating that “in real‑life situations, these devices are unreliable at best, and often simply don’t work.”

A monitored alarm offers something very different: consistent, dependable support from trained professionals who respond every time. With 24/7 monitoring, you and your loved ones can feel confident knowing that help is always available and that a caring responder will take action the moment you need it.

Ultimately, the right personal alarm is the one that helps you feel secure, supported and in control. A monitored service provides that extra layer of protection, so you can live independently with greater confidence.

‍

Ready to take the first step? We're here to help! Our team can help you choose the best alarm for your needs. Contact Us